Bright contemporary Windsor home interior with an oak kitchen island, a small dining area and a window overlooking a quiet autumn garden.

What a New Home in Windsor Costs This Fall, Next to Resale

November 19, 2026

In October 2026, the 25 residential sales that closed in Windsor through the BAREIS MLS averaged $797,669 and spent an average of 60 days on market. On Amanda Way, off Old Redwood Highway near Merner Drive, a finished three-bedroom, 2.5-bath house of 1,869 square feet is listed by its builder at $699,990, and it is marked as a quick move-in home.

Both new-home communities selling in town list their starting prices about $100,000 under October's resale average. One of them is also advertising five-figure savings on homes that are already finished. A buyer comparing new and resale in Windsor this November should weigh the builder's discount on a finished house before anything else.

Two Communities, Both Starting Near $700,000

Old Redwood Village is Ryder Homes' 29-home subdivision at 6122 Old Redwood Highway. It has two two-story floor plans. Plan 2 is 1,869 square feet and priced from $734,990. Plan 3 is 1,887 square feet with a loft, priced from $699,990 with solar included. As of mid-November, Ryder showed seven available homes listed between $699,990 and $799,990. The top of that range is the model home at 141 Amanda Way. The Housing Land Trust of the North Bay says the subdivision was built between 2025 and 2026. Three of its homes are affordable units under a partnership among the Town of Windsor, Ryder Homes and the land trust. Two common open spaces with a playground and a shared garden sit at its northwest and southwest corners.

Hummingbird Lane is Christopherson Builders' community near Robbins Park in southeast Windsor. Its featured home is at 357 Cornell Street, and the builder lists homes "starting at $699K." The plans range from 1,395 square feet, with three bedrooms and a one-car garage, to 3,366 square feet. The featured Plan 3 home has an attached ADU studio with its own side entrance, a covered loggia with an outdoor kitchen, and an owned rooftop solar system. The Housing Land Trust's project page describes 24 single-family and duet homes on 5.1 acres, two of them land-trust units, with construction started in 2025. Two acres are set aside as permanent public open space next to Robbins Park.

Old Redwood Village Hummingbird Lane
Builder Ryder Homes Christopherson Builders
Location Old Redwood Hwy at Merner Dr Near Robbins Park, southeast Windsor
Total homes 29 24
Plan sizes 1,869 to 1,887 sq ft 1,395 to 3,366 sq ft
Builder's listed pricing, mid-November 2026 $699,990 to $799,990 From $699K
Status shown on builder site, mid-November 2026 7 homes available 4 available, 3 sold, 2 reserved, 15 future

The two communities are at different stages. At Old Redwood Village, the homes are built. Ryder's listing pages show move-in dates of October 16 and October 23, 2026, so by the last week of November these houses are finished and waiting for buyers. Hummingbird Lane is earlier along, with 15 of its 24 homes still listed as future homes. Christopherson currently shows the community by appointment only.

What the Resale Average Is Made Of

Windsor's resale figures move a lot from month to month, and a buyer should know why before comparing them to a builder's price. BAREIS reports Windsor closings as averages, not medians. In August 2026, 29 residential sales averaged $708,594 with 77 days on market. In September 2026, 15 sales averaged $744,827 with 75 days on market. October brought 25 sales averaging $797,669 and 60 days.

When only 15 to 29 houses change hands in a month, a few larger homes can lift the average by tens of thousands of dollars without any house becoming worth more. The roughly $89,000 rise from August to October tells you which homes sold in October more than it tells you what a given house is worth. The steadier finding is that across all three months, Windsor's average resale price was at or above $699,990, the price on Ryder's least expensive finished homes.

The county as a whole runs higher. The California Association of Realtors put Sonoma County's September 2026 median for existing single-family homes at $875,000, up 10.1% from September 2025. County unsold inventory that month was 4.0 months, and median time on market was 61 days. Next to that county figure, a new three-bedroom near $700,000 in Windsor is priced close to the floor of the county's single-family market.

The comparison has limits. The resale average mixes every size, age and lot in town, and the builder's price is for one specific product: a two-story home of about 1,870 to 1,890 square feet on Old Redwood Highway, or a Hummingbird Lane plan near Robbins Park. Resale homes in Windsor are not all overpriced, and new homes are not automatically a better deal. The point is narrower. A buyer whose budget fits a Windsor resale home right now can also afford a brand-new one in the same town.

Where the Builder's Price Moves

On a resale home, the asking price is the number you negotiate. With a builder, the room is in what the builder is already advertising. Ryder's Old Redwood Village page currently promotes "amazing deals for all move-in ready homes." The listing for 159 Amanda Way, a Plan 2 home on homesite 21 described as move-in ready with premium upgrades, carries a "SAVE OVER $73K!" banner.

The timing explains where the room is. Ryder's finished homes carried October move-in dates and are still listed in late November, and the builder has attached five-figure savings to them. Windsor's resale homes averaged 60 days on market in October, with no comparable advertised discount behind the average.

A buyer touring Old Redwood Village or Hummingbird Lane will get more out of the visit by bringing a few specific questions. The first is what the advertised savings are measured against, whether a base price, an earlier list price or included upgrades, and whether any of that value can go toward closing costs or a rate buydown instead of the price. Neither builder's pages state HOA dues, so get the monthly figure and any other recurring assessments in writing. At Hummingbird Lane, the Plan 3 ADU studio raises its own questions about metering and access, and at Old Redwood Village it is fair to find out whether the savings extend to the model at 141 Amanda Way.

Resale still has things a builder's lot can't match: mature trees, established yards, and Windsor's older neighborhoods. A buyer who wants those should know that the new homes in town set a price that resale sellers are competing against this season. A move-in-ready new house listed below the town's October average is a useful reference point when you write an offer on a 20-year-old house nearby.

The Next Wave Is Further Out

These two communities are most of the new for-sale construction in Windsor right now. The town's largest approved subdivision is Quail Acres. It is 301 homes on 59 acres along Arata Lane in northeast Windsor, plus 98 ADUs and 119 junior ADUs, on lots from just under 1,200 square feet to a little over 2,500, according to the Press Democrat. The Planning Commission approved it again in May 2025, and the Town of Windsor's project page records 30 affordable for-sale homes in the plan. In July 2025, the developer, Redwood Equities, reached a $3.75 million agreement with Windsor Unified that cleared the way for construction, and its spokesperson told the Press Democrat that Redwood "wants to move as quickly as possible." The same Town page lists the developer's submittal of a final map and improvement plans as the next step.

For a buyer shopping new construction in Windsor this winter, the choices are the finished inventory at Old Redwood Village and the four homes Christopherson lists as available at Hummingbird Lane. Quail Acres is a reason some buyers may wait, but its homes are not on the market today.

Transit is also on a longer timeline. Windsor is the northern end of the SMART line for now, and SMART's Healdsburg extension page lists passenger service north of Windsor beginning in December 2028. Old Redwood Village is on Old Redwood Highway, the same corridor that runs past the Town Green and the station. Evenings on that corridor are covered in our post on Windsor Road after dark, and summers there in Summer on the Windsor Town Green. For a broader look at the town, see the Windsor neighborhood guide.

If you're deciding between a finished new home on Amanda Way, a Hummingbird Lane plan, and a resale house a few streets away, bring the question to Alexander Goodman and we'll set the builder's current offer beside recent Windsor sales together. If you own a Windsor home and want to know how it compares with these new listings, start with a home valuation or let's connect.

Work With Alex

Experience a client-focused approach backed by local knowledge, honest communication, and dedication to your success.